Fantasy Booking: An Experiment - The Forum Books BOA '19

[Ghost]

My dying bride 5pt
Overkill 4pt
Abbath 3pt
Exodus 2pt
Clutch 1pt

[Tet]

5 - Accept
4 - Gamma Ray (too expensive - it'll never happen)
3 - Epica
2 - Saxon
1 - Abbath

[dclizardking]

Exodus = 5 points
Clutch = 4 points
Overkill = 3 points
Accept = 2 points
Saxon = 1 point

[kurrupo]

5pts - Children of Bodom
4pts - Clutch
3pts - Saxon
2pts - Abbath
1pt - Exodus

[jwh20]

Accept - 5
My Dying Bride - 4
Exodus - 3
Gamma Ray - 2
Abbath - 1

I'd rather shit in my hands and clap than watch Epica again

[Soze]

5pts Exodus
4pts Overkill
3pts Saxon
2pt Abbath
1pt Accept

I don't think Gamma Ray are big enough in the UK to warrant the hour slot personally...and if there was any chance of this festival happening I'd be concerned at the complete lack of extreme metal so far (considering how big a crowd these bands normally attract!).

[pinhead0303]

5pts Abbath
4pts Overkill
3pts Accept
2pts Saxon
1pt Exodus

[Jay1993]

5pts Exodus
4pts Overkill
3pts Saxon
2pt Abbath
1pt Accept

I don't think Gamma Ray are big enough in the UK to warrant the hour slot personally...and if there was any chance of this festival happening I'd be concerned at the complete lack of extreme metal so far (considering how big a crowd these bands normally attract!).

I agree, looking a bit tame so far

[pinhead0303]

5pts Exodus
4pts Overkill
3pts Saxon
2pt Abbath
1pt Accept

I don't think Gamma Ray are big enough in the UK to warrant the hour slot personally...and if there was any chance of this festival happening I'd be concerned at the complete lack of extreme metal so far (considering how big a crowd these bands normally attract!).

I agree, looking a bit tame so far

Don't worry, we'll be voting Hatebreed in for you soon

[Haldamir319]

As it stands:

34 - Exodus
28 - Overkill
23 - Abbath
20 - Accept
19 - Saxon
18 - Clutch
14 - My Dying Bride
11 - Children of Bodom
8 - Gamma Ray
6 - Epica

I'll leave this open until tonight.

[Haldamir319]

Might as well add mine, actually:

5pts - Saxon
4pts - Accept
3pts - Clutch
2pts - Abbath
1pt - Epica


Update scores:

34 - Exodus
28 - Overkill
25 - Abbath
24 - Accept / Saxon
21 - Clutch
14 - My Dying Bride
11 - Children of Bodom
8 - Gamma Ray
7 - Epica

Outside of a rush of non-thrash fans, it looks like Exodus are there. Looks like its between Overkill, Accept, Saxon and Clutch for the remaining two spots.

[Soze]

On a personal level I'd much rather have Saxon or Accept than Abbath but for the sake of variety I'm hoping he nabs one of the spots!

[florencethemachine]

Cannot believe I nearly missed a good listing/scoring opportunity.

5pts - My Dying Bride
4pts - Saxon
3pts - Abbath
2pts - Accept
1pts - Exodus

[red_death]

Accept 5
Saxon 4
Overkill 3
Meshuggah 2
Abbath 1

[Haldamir319]

I suspect Abbath could fit one slot lower down.